How much money is enough money?

4
Is that enough?

It depends

You have probably heard that question before and it is one similar to “What would I do if win the lottery?” as they are both very vague and expect no actual answer other than “it depends”.

However, let us try to frame that question from the perspective of a couple that is aiming at becoming financially independent and who are willing to prepare for the most important expense of their life : their retirement years. If you can figure out how to get prepared for your retirement, you will probably find it easier planning for intermediate expenses along the way (houses, kids education, …).

In addition to retirement being the largest expense to plan for, in many developed countries, the pension system is broke. Our financial savvy couple has better have a plan to have enough money when the time to retire comes, especially if they are currently in their 20s or 30s: there will likely be no retirement or nothing meaningful to support your life-style.

So don’t count on it and start building your own retirement pot.

How much money is enough money to retire?

In 1994, a retired financial advisor William Bengen first articulated the idea that in order to have enjoy retirement in the US for 30 years without running out of cash from its investments, one would need to limit its yearly withdrawals to about 4%. This became famous in 1998 when the Trinity Study was released and the “4%” rule became a rule of thumb to help people evaluate the amount of money they would need to retire. If you have a retirement pot of 1,000,000$, you can expect to withdraw an average of 40,000$ a year and live off of it.

The corollary of this rule is that you have an investment total of 25 times your yearly spend. If you currently spend a total of 60,000$ a year, you will need 1.5M$ (bear in mind this isn’t adjusted for inflation, if you plan on retiring in 30 years, this 1.5M$ of 2014 dollars will become close to 2.5-3M$ of 2045 dollars).

Your Savings Rate

If we push the analysis a little further and we take into consideration the yearly spend, the targeted 25 * yearly spend, we can estimate how many years of savings are required for a given Savings Rate. You will see the correlation in the graph below, based on a few assumptions:

  • 100% of the savings are invested every year,
  • the average return on investment is 8%,
  • the starting wealth is 0$.

Savings Rate

As an example, for a gross income of 100,000$, the net income is 73,000$ (after 27% tax) and a 30% Savings Rate is 21,900$, or the equivalent of 1,825$ set aside every month. If your company provides Discounted Stock Plan, Yearly Bonus, Housing,… those amounts add to your net income but also to your savings, therefore increasing your Savings Rate. If your company has a 401k you’re contributing to, the same method applies but you will need to consider the pre-tax nature of your contributions in your calculations.

You will note that to be able to retire at 67 if you have started to work at 24 (43 years of contributions), this model shows you will need around 7-8% of Savings Rate.

Now we have shown that our future quality of retirement is based on 3 variables :

  • The expected Quality of your Retirement,
  • The Time Horizon you have to build savings and investments,
  • The Savings Rate that you can support.

Those 3 elements are interconnected: with a higher Savings Rate, you can expect a higher Quality of Retirement and conversely, a lower Time Horizon will necessarily translate into a higher Savings Rate (unless you can accept a lower Quality of Retirement).

The Time Horizon is pretty easy to figure out, the expected Quality of your Retirement is usually “at least as good as today”, so that leaves us with Savings Rate.

The Awakening

Of course, this model is not meant to be the answer to exactly how much Savings Rate is required for each individual to be plan for Financial Independence at or before retirement age, but is really meant to provide the tools and a baseline for everyone to plan today for an event possibly 30 years in the future. And this, today, is badly needed.

Here are some facts:

  • The average Savings Rate in the US as of November 2014 stands at 4.4%, according to the Federal Reserve, one of the lowest rates since 1960. This is way below the estimated minimum 7-8% rate we calculated above.
  • More than half of the US Household are “Financially Unprepared” for retirement in 2013, the highest level ever recorded.

Now, more than ever is a really good time to check spending habits, estimate retirement needs with 25 * spending and identify a Savings Rate that will help achieve a reasonably comfortable retirement.

And then, when we eventually retire, if the government’s pension system isn’t broke and we aren’t working till 80 years, we’ll be ready and we’ll consider ourselves lucky.

Dear readers, I am curious as to how many of you have managed so far to keep their Savings Rate above the 8% calculated above and if any has stories how they managed it?

Get Free Email Updates!

Enjoyed this article? Join our Financial Independence newsletter.

I will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.

SHARE
Previous articleWhy should you invest?
Next articleBecome a Millionaire

4 COMMENTS

  1. really do I save at least 8%? this is a good question, but I am not really sure of how much I am saving consistently every year, nonetheless every month! every time it changes…. I never thought I needed a monthly target.

  2. Nina –
    Of course it can sometimes be difficult to maintain the exact same level every month, there is always an element of ‘unplanned’ spend even with the most accurate forecast. But then you know by how much you missed your target and give yourself a chance to fix it the following month(s).

    But typically, the only spend source that varies a lot is the credit card spend (utilities, rent, gas, insurance, … are all relatively stable).
    See you much you net income you get in 1 year, how much you spend in 1 year, look at the savings rate you’d like to achieve depending on when you’d like to retire and set yourself a monthly spend target for your credit card. Some banks can send you a text message when you reach a certain spend. That’s even easier!

    The most important is to start!
    Then as time goes you’ll get better at it 🙂

    Nick

  3. I’ve been saving around 50% of my income for years, but I don’t know if this rate of savings will be feasible for the future. I think I will transition to a lower paid career and that will impact our financials, but hopefully make us happier. If we’ll get to a point where our rentals/investments pay for most of our expenses, I won’t be so concerned about saving as I’ve been so far.

    • Felix – congrats for savings around 50% for years, this is something relatively new for me so you’re already far ahead! You say you already have several rentals in addition to your investments, that should bring much closer to FI no?

Leave a Reply